How to Handle a Denied Auto Insurance Claim

Imagine you’re in a car accident and submit a claim to your insurance company, only to receive a denial letter. You’re left wondering what went wrong and how to proceed. Handling a denied auto insurance claim can save you time, money, and stress.

Short Summary

  • Review policy, collect evidence, and contact the insurance company after a claim denial.
  • Draft an appeal letter, seek legal assistance, or file a complaint with the state commissioner for Action.
  • Maintain accurate information, choose adequate coverage, and understand exclusions to prevent future denials.

Reasons You Might Need an Auto Insurance Claim Lawyer for First-Party Claims:

  • Unjust Denials: If your insurance company denies your claim without an apparent reason or based on ambiguous policy language, it’s crucial to have legal experts who can challenge and clarify these decisions.
  • Underpaid Claims: When the compensation offered doesn’t cover the damages or is far below your policy’s entitled amount, a seasoned lawyer can help ensure you receive what’s rightfully yours.
  • Policy Interpretation: Insurance contracts can be dense and full of legalese. A dedicated legal team ensures that your policy is interpreted correctly, protecting your interests.
  • Delayed Payments: Legal intervention might be necessary to expedite your compensation if you’re experiencing unwarranted delays in claim settlements.

Why Call Leader, Leader & Zucker for a Free Consultation on First-Party Auto Insurance Claims?

  • Unparalleled Expertise: Having handled countless first-party auto insurance disputes, Leader, Leader & Zucker has the insights and strategies to approach your claim precisely.
  • Client First Philosophy: Your concerns are our top priority. We provide attentive service, keeping you informed and supported throughout the claim process.
  • Risk-Free Evaluation: Discover the potential strengths of your claim and the best path forward without any initial costs.
  • Driven by Results: Our commitment isn’t just to serve but to succeed. We strive for the best possible outcome, ensuring your interests are safeguarded against insurance giants.

Understanding the Denial of Your Auto Insurance Claim

A car insurance company denying a claim

Insurance claims can be denied for various reasons, from expired policies to policy exclusions or inadequate coverage. Understanding why your claim was denied is crucial to determining the best action.

The following sections delve into the most common reasons for denied claims and how to address them.

Expired or Lapsed Policy

An expired or lapsed policy occurs when the insurance premium is not paid on time, causing an interruption in coverage. Your claim will likely be denied if you’re involved in an accident and your policy has expired or lapsed.

Pay your premiums on time to avoid this issue and keep track of your policy’s expiration date.

Policy Exclusions

Exclusions are essential for an insurance policy. These clauses explicitly state which kinds of accidents or damages the policy will not cover. For example, if your policy excludes damage caused by driving off-road and you have an accident while off-roading, your claim may be denied.

To avoid denied claims due to policy exclusions, reviewing your policy and understanding what is not covered thoroughly is essential. If your claim is denied based on an exclusion, you may still appeal the decision and provide evidence that the exclusion does not apply to your situation.

Inadequate Coverage

Inadequate coverage refers to insurance coverage that is not sufficient to protect you from loss or expense. Your claim may be denied or only partially paid if your policy limits do not cover the damages or medical costs incurred in an accident.

To avoid this issue, carefully assess your insurance needs and choose a policy with coverage limits that provide adequate protection.

Steps to Take After Your Car Insurance Claim is Denied

A person reviewing their car insurance policy

If your denied car insurance claim is causing you stress, it’s important not to panic. You can take steps to address the situation, such as reviewing your policy, gathering evidence, and contacting your insurance company to discuss the denial of the car insurance claim.

In the following sections, we’ll discuss these steps in detail and guide how to proceed.

Review Your Policy

After receiving an insurance claim denial, the first step is to review your insurance policy. Ensure you understand the coverage, limits, exclusions, and any changes that may have occurred since you last reviewed your policy. By reviewing your policy, you can identify any discrepancies between your coverage and the coverage required for your claim.

Contact your insurance company to discuss the issue if you find any inconsistencies.

Gather Evidence

Gathering evidence to support your claim is crucial in the event of a denied claim. This may include accident scene photographs, eyewitness statements, police reports, and medical records. Additionally, gather any documentation related to the damages incurred, such as repair estimates and towing costs.

If your claim involves injuries, be sure to obtain copies of all medical bills and records, as well as documentation of any lost wages due to the accident. By gathering comprehensive evidence, you can demonstrate the validity of your claim and potentially convince your insurance company to reconsider their decision.

Contact Your Insurance Company

After reviewing your policy and gathering evidence, contact your car insurance company to discuss the denial. Be prepared to provide the evidence you’ve collected and ask for clarification on the reasons for the denial. If you believe the denial is unjust, request a reconsideration of their decision.

Keep in mind that maintaining open communication with your insurance company is crucial throughout the claims process.

Appealing the Denied Auto Insurance Claim

If your claim is still denied after discussing the issue with your insurance company, you may consider appealing the decision. In the following sections, we’ll outline the steps in appealing a denied auto insurance claim, including drafting an appeal letter, seeking legal assistance, and filing a complaint with the state insurance commissioner.

Drafting an appeal letter is the first step in the process. This letter should include the following:

Draft an Appeal Letter

An appeal letter is a formal document written to the insurance company requesting a review of the decision. Include the supporting evidence and information you’ve gathered to substantiate your claim in the letter. Be sure to address the specific reasons for the denial mentioned in the denial letter and explain why you believe the decision is unjust.

Send the appeal letter to your insurance company, and keep a copy for your records.

Seek Legal Assistance

If your appeal is denied or unresolved, seeking legal assistance from an experienced attorney may be beneficial. A lawyer specializing in denied insurance claims can help you navigate the appeals process and provide guidance on your legal options.

In some cases, an auto accident attorney may be able to negotiate a fair settlement with the insurance company on your behalf.

File a Complaint with State Insurance Commissioner

If your appeal remains unresolved after seeking legal assistance, consider filing a complaint with your state’s insurance commissioner. To file a complaint, gather all relevant documents and information, such as copies of your policy, communication with the insurance company, and any other documents that might be applicable. The complaint can be submitted either online or by mail, and it’s essential to include all relevant documents and information.

After submitting the complaint, contact the state insurance commissioner to ensure your complaint is being handled.

Dealing with Uninsured Motorist Coverage

Uninsured motorist coverage is an essential aspect of auto insurance, as it provides protection against drivers without sufficient insurance. In the following sections, we’ll discuss the importance of uninsured motorist coverage and how to claim it in an accident involving an uninsured driver.

Uninsured motorist coverage is important because it can help cover the costs of medical bills, car insurance, and other expenses.

Importance of Uninsured Motorist Coverage

Uninsured motorist coverage is crucial for protecting yourself against drivers without adequate insurance. If you’re involved in an accident with an uninsured driver, having uninsured motorist coverage can help cover medical expenses, vehicle damage, and other losses that might not be covered by the at-fault driver’s insurance.

Without this coverage, you may be left with significant financial burdens.

Claiming Uninsured Motorist Coverage

To claim uninsured motorist coverage, you must provide evidence of the other driver’s lack of insurance and the damages incurred. This may include a police report, medical bills, and repair estimates.

Keep in mind that the process for claiming uninsured motorist coverage may vary depending on your insurance company and state laws. If you’re unsure how to proceed, consult an experienced car accident lawyer for guidance.

Bad Faith Insurance Practices

Bad faith insurance practices can lead to denied claims and additional stress for policyholders. In the following sections, we’ll discuss how to identify these practices and explore the legal options available to address them.

Insurance companies have a duty to act in good faith when dealing with policyholders. This means that everything has been changed.

Identifying Bad Faith Practices

Identifying bad faith practices involves recognizing unreasonable claim denials, delays, or low settlement offers. If you suspect that your insurance company is engaging in bad faith practices, it’s essential to document all communication with them and gather any supporting evidence that may demonstrate their misconduct.

By being vigilant and proactive, you can protect yourself against bad faith practices and ensure your claim is handled fairly.

Legal Options for Bad Faith Claims

If you believe you’re a victim of bad faith insurance practices, it’s important to explore your legal options. Hiring an attorney experienced in bad faith claims can help you navigate the legal process and potentially file a lawsuit against the insurance company. They can also provide guidance on the best course of action for your specific situation and help ensure that your rights are protected throughout the process.

Bad faith insurance claims can be complex and difficult to prove. An experienced attorney can help you.

Tips for Preventing Future Claim Denials

While you can’t prevent every claim denial, there are steps you can take to minimize the chances of a denied claim in the future. In the following sections, we’ll provide tips on maintaining accurate information, choosing adequate coverage, and understanding policy exclusions to help you avoid potential claim denials.

Maintaining accurate information is key to avoiding claim denials. Make sure to keep all your records.

Maintain Accurate Information

Maintaining accurate information on your policy is crucial for avoiding potential issues with future claims. Regularly review your policy to ensure all details are up to date, including your contact information, vehicle information, and coverage limits.

Notify your insurance company of any changes in your circumstances, such as a change of address or the acquisition of a new vehicle, to avoid any discrepancies that could lead to a denied claim.

Choose Adequate Coverage

Selecting adequate coverage is essential for ensuring sufficient protection in the event of an accident. Take the time to assess your insurance needs and choose a policy with coverage limits that provide adequate protection for your specific situation.

Regularly review your policy to ensure it continues to meet your needs and adjust your coverage limits as necessary.

Understand Policy Exclusions

Understanding policy exclusions can help prevent future claim denials. Review your policy to identify any exclusions that may apply to your specific situation and ensure you’re aware of what is not covered by your insurance.

If you have questions or concerns about your policy exclusions, contact your car insurance company for clarification.


In conclusion, dealing with a denied auto insurance claim can be a challenging and stressful experience. However, by understanding the reasons behind claim denials, taking the appropriate steps after a denial, and being proactive in preventing future denials, you can protect yourself and ensure that your claims are handled fairly. Stay informed, communicate with your insurance company, and seek legal assistance when necessary to navigate the complex world of auto insurance claims.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I resolve a denied claim?

To resolve a denied claim, review the reason for the denial, gather supporting documentation, appeal the denial and negotiate with the insurance company. Additionally, take a step-by-step approach, starting by finding out why your claim was denied, calling your insurance provider, doctor’s office and collecting paperwork, then submitting an internal appeal and waiting for an answer.

What is a common reason a car insurance claim could be denied?

Insurance claims can be denied due to driving without a license, exceeding the speed limit, DUI, or illegal modifications to the vehicle.

These are all serious offenses that can result in a claim being denied. It is important to understand the laws and regulations in your area to ensure that you are not putting yourself at risk of having a claim denied.

How often are insurance claims denied?

It is estimated that approximately 1 in 7 insurance claims are denied across the healthcare industry, with denial rates ranging from 10% to 42%, depending on the issuer.

What happens if an insurance claim is denied?

If an insurance claim is denied, you can appeal the decision and have it reviewed by a third party. You must also receive either payment or a written denial from the insurer within 90 days and may be entitled to interest if the claim is not paid or denied by the deadline.

Understanding the appeals process and the timeline for payment or denial of a claim is important. Knowing your rights and the steps to take can help ensure you receive the compensation you are entitled to.

What is uninsured motorist coverage?

Uninsured motorist coverage protects in the event of an accident caused by a driver who does not have enough insurance to cover the costs of damage and injuries.

It can help to pay for medical bills, lost wages, and other expenses that may arise from the accident. It can also provide coverage for damage to your vehicle if the other driver is at fault.

This type of coverage is important.


What Our Clients Say

Michael, Thank you so much for all of our support and diligence over the past seven months. That was the most trying and difficult time of my life. Michael’s legal expertise was top notch.
Michael, Thank you so much for all of our support and diligence over the past seven months. That was the most trying and difficult time of my life. Michael’s legal expertise was top notch.
More Clients Review


Top Lawyers Florida
Super Lawyers
10 Best Client Satisfaction
Top 100 National Trial Lawyers

Free Consultation Request

Discover how we can help you.


Innovative – Skilled – Experienced – Knowledgeable – Aggressive

633 South Andrews Ave Suite 201
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301


Michael, Thank you so much for all of our support and diligence over the past seven months. That was the most trying and difficult time of my life. Michael’s legal expertise was top notch.
Michael, Thank you so much for all of our support and diligence over the past seven months. That was the most trying and difficult time of my life. Michael’s legal expertise was top notch.